Some Things Don’t Work

A while ago, when I had extra time to write between contracts, I decided to self-publish some supernatural mysteries because I enjoy writing them so much.  I knew it was a bit of a risk since urban fantasy is still pretty glutted, but I’d seen some paranormal witch mysteries that were doing well on Amazon and thought it was worth a try.  I had a lot of fun writing them, but I’ve given them a decent shot, and they’re still dead in the water.  I can’t get them off the ground.  So I came to a crossroads.  Do I keep writing them and hope the fifth or sixth one clicks, or do I admit defeat and try something new?

My agent loved the urban fantasies I wrote forever ago but got one rejection after another because no one was buying UF anymore.  I spent a lot of years trying to sell stories that no matter how well done, no one wanted to buy.  And I don’t want to do that again.  So this time, I’m throwing the towel in early.  Right or wrong, I’ve learned the hard way that some things are easier to sell than others.  So I felt sorry for myself, licked my wounded pride for a day, and then sat down and started to work on something different.  I don’t want to write a second cozy series.  I know a lot of writers juggle two or more of them, but I’d have too much trouble trying to keep track of which is which if they were that much alike.  I mean, cozies have some similarities.  If I’m going to do a second series, it has to be different enough from Jazzi to help me find balance between the two.

I’m sharing this, not to garner sympathy, but because when I like writing something, that’s what I want to write.  I don’t want to change or go in a different direction.  But I’ve found that I need to.  When my agent asked me to try to write a romance, I didn’t want to.  I’d never considered it.  Ever.  The plot points felt weird to me–hurt feelings and misunderstandings instead of attacks and battles.  The thing is, I learned a lot by writing the Mill Pond series.  I had to concentrate on character more than plot, and my tacklebox of writing tools grew richer for it.  I took some of those tools with me when my editor asked if I’d like to try my hand at a mystery.

This might sound crazy to you, but if you’re writing really well but your work won’t sell, maybe you should try something outside your comfort zone.  There’s so much to writing that we can’t control.  If editors decide a market is tight or dead, soon it will be, because they won’t buy anything in that genre.  If the market really is glutted, it’s even hard to find readers if you self-publish.  There are just too many things for them to choose from.  Markets come and go.  Literary fiction, I’m told, is a hard sell right now.  Sometimes, selling comes down to a current preference.  It’s harder to sell writing in present tense  now because there’s a bias against it.  Some editors prefer third person, single POV, over first person.  Some of that depends on what genre you write in, but I’ve read reviews where readers prefer third over first.  That doesn’t mean what you write won’t sell, but it means it will be harder.

For now, I’m going to try something new.  A straight mystery instead of a supernatural.  And I’m writing it in first person.  Then I’ll see what happens.  But it doesn’t hurt to flex your writing muscles and experiment a little.  You can start with something short and go from there.  Maybe try a one-hour read.  Play with a new genre, a different style.  But it’s hard to put your best into something, over and over again, know that it’s good (and I’m not just talking ego or confidence here, but comments from critique partners and editors or agents), and keep getting rejections.  When that happens, it might not have anything to do with how well you write, but a lot to do with what you write.  But let’s face it.  In writing, there’s no one right answer, and what works for one person doesn’t work for someone else.  But I’m ready to try to tilt the odds in my favor instead of against me.  So wish me luck.  And good luck to you and whatever you’re working on and Happy Writing!

 

7 thoughts on “Some Things Don’t Work

  1. Mae Clair

    Does this mean you’re abandoning your Muddy River series? That’s so sad because I really loved that, and honestly I don’t normally read books with paranormal characters. Yet your story telling sucked me in.

    I look forward to your venture into straight mystery. I have no doubt you will rock it. I think it’s extremely hard to make headway as an indie author regardless of genre. It takes a lot of promo $$$ to get noticed, and most authors can’t afford to part with those. I know I’m not looking forward into navigating those waters!

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply
    1. Judi Lynn Post author

      You gave me lots of hope for Muddy River, Mae, but I feel like I’m banging my head against a wall. I thought it had been long enough that supernatural/urban fantasy might be safe again, but I think it’s still going to be an uphill battle. When I looked at ads for it, it was one of the smallest markets with the least readers signed up for it. I’m hoping I’ll find a larger audience with straight mystery. But thanks for all the encouragement. I really appreciated it.

      Liked by 1 person

      Reply
  2. coldhandboyack

    I have these worries all the time. While there is always room for improvement, I think I provide a fairly good story. Since writing isn’t paying the bills around here, I just write what motivates me. If it’s a weird sub-genre, so be it. If it were paying the bills, I’d have to make decisions like you are.

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply
  3. Sue Bahr

    Around it goes! I enjoyed your urban fantasies- they were edgy and dynamic. But I guess you’re right that you learn from trying something new. First person can be amazing – how you filter the story from one point of view and how that pov slants the perspective on others and on the plot.

    Sorry I haven’t been reading your posts, Judy. My Email has decided all WordPress posts are spam and I can’t seem to change it!
    Hugs and keep on keeping on!
    Sue

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply

Leave a Reply to coldhandboyack Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s