A long time ago, when I was experimenting with different genres to write, I sold some dark, quirky short stories. When I gave one of them to a fellow writer to critique, she said “You can’t use a happy word when you write dark fiction. It breaks the mood.” I’d described a forest with trees with dark, gnarled branches and then had birds hopping on the them overhead. Wrong. Happy birds don’t belong in gnarled forests. Ravens hovering might work with a gray, moody sky. But I realized that every word had to add to the tone of the story.
Once I started writing longer fiction, and tried my hand at even more genres, I realized that page after page of suspense or moody prose could use a break here or there, so I started to use humor as a relief occasionally. Sometimes the humor even made the dire circumstances more dire when I returned to it. But the humor had to be brief. And its tone had to match the tone of the story.
Once I started writing cozies, I could use humor to jazz up a scene or two. Humor added nice variety to digging for clues, and it could show relationships in a different light. It gave the entire manuscript a lighter feel. I like humor. I like using it, but I’m no pro. C.S. Boyack uses a lot of humor in his stories, and he does it well. He used the root monsters in his Voyage of the Lanternfish to add comic relief to his tale of a good man who had to turn to piracy to fight an oppressive government, and a lot of readers fell in love with the odd little vegetable men. I know I did. https://www.amazon.com/Voyage-Lanternfish-C-S-Boyack-ebook/dp/B07MP8V633/ref=sr_1_3?dchild=1&keywords=c.s.+boyack&qid=1613058898&sr=8-3
Boyack uses humor so often, he wrote two blogs about it for Story Empire, giving examples of different kinds of humor and how to use it: Expansion Pack: The Return of Comedy | Story Empire (wordpress.com) I read both posts and enjoyed them. And sometimes, serendipity happens, because right after reading the post about using “misunderstanding” for a chuckle or two, I started reading a book that uses that type of humor to wonderful effect–The Fear Hunter, by Elise Sax.
I’ve read a few suspense books back to back recently, and I have to admit the lighthearted cozy feel of a witch who’s out of touch with modern society trying to solve a crime is a delightful treat at the end of the day. Humor is subjective, and for me, Sax’s constant light touch is spot on.
I’d be remiss if I didn’t mention that Julia Donner’s sly humor in her Regency romances is one of the reasons I love her books. Dry wit takes a special skill. I’m adding a link to one of her Regencies, so you can check it out if you like historical romances with underlying humor: To Jilt a Corinthian (Friendship Series Book 12) – Kindle edition by Donner, Julia. Romance Kindle eBooks @ Amazon.com.
I don’t know if you like to read or write humor. It won’t work in the new series I’ve just started, but it adds a lot to any cozy I write. Whether it works for you or not, happy reading and even better, happy writing!
Iām so glad you enjoyed the posts. Iām ecstatic that you enjoyed the first Lanternfish book. Thanks for telling your fans about it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I love the root monsters!
Great examples in this post, both your own cheerful birds in an ominous woodland and the other authors you referenced.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I love the root monsters, too. Seriously, who can resist those guys?
I’m also a fan of dry humor and think Julia does it perfectly in her Regencies.
I’ve used it a time or two to lighten mood in a darker piece, because as you said…..all that somberness can use a break now and then.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thank you, Judi, for sharing your insights, and for high-lighting Craig. He’s excellent in bringing laughter or lightheartedness into a situation. Bravo to you both!
LikeLiked by 2 people
Great mention of Craig today, Judi. š
LikeLiked by 2 people
I’m a huge fan of humor in writing, including those wonder root monsters. Great post š
LikeLiked by 2 people